ROCK PAPER WATCH

‘Man of Steel’ Character Flaws and That Ending

2 Comments

superman_in_man_of_steel-HD

No one was more excited about this Superman reboot than I was.  I grew up in a family that LOVES Superman.  I read the comics with my dad as a kid and watched the movies with my mom.  I remember her crying when Christopher Reeve was paralyzed and even more so when he passed.  After the failed attempt at bringing Superman back in 2006 and all the recent superhero hoopla, it was time for a successful depiction of the Man of Steel.  When production was announced in 2010 I was ecstatic.  When I found out Christopher Nolan, the man behind Batman’s successful reboot, was involved my expectations went through the roof.  When Henry Cavill, my longtime Tudors crush, was cast I knew it was all too good to be true.  And guess what guys, it was.

Before I say anything else I should probably let you know that this post is going to be slammed full of SPOILERS.  If you haven’t seen Man of Steel then stop reading because I am going to ruin it for you.

In 2010, David S. Goyer approached Christopher Nolan with an idea of how to bring back Superman.  Much like Superman in the Dark Knight trilogy, he’ll exist in a world where he’s the only superhero and it will be an origin story that stands on it’s own.  The goal of this reboot was to reinvent Superman, the main idea being that a “perfect” superhero is now stagnant in today’s society.  Moviegoers prefer complex superheroes (see the philosophies and Christ-like themes behind The Dark Knight and Rises in which Batman acts as a  martyr for society).

Don’t get me wrong, there were some parts of this reinvention that I thoroughly enjoyed.  I like that the story tapped into a darkness in Superman and I agree a “perfect” Superman is boring.  In the reboot, we are told Clark Kent’s background in flashbacks.  One of the more powerful scenes is when he gains his x-ray vision and can suddenly see the bones and muscles inside his elementary school teacher.  Stunned by fear, Clark takes shelter in a janitorial closet until his mother (Diane Lane) can coax him out.  The links to stigmas around autism are noticeable.  From there, it is clear that this is a Superman that is afraid.  When his father (Kevin Costner) tells him of his origin, Clark sheepishly asks “Can’t I just keep being your son?” and your heart melts.  Not only is he afraid, but this is a Superman that longs to be accepted and feel at home. While this is a defining characteristic, the most important one is Superman’s need to help people.  Through flashbacks, we see several instances in his childhood and adulthood where his need to save someone outweighs his need to belong.  We learn that his father believed the world wasn’t ready for him, they would shun him when they learned of his existence.  This fear makes Clark a loner and drifter, working odd-end jobs and quickly moving to the next after he saves someone’s life.  In probably the most moving scene, a tornado strikes Kansas and takes the life of Jonathan Kent.  Clark could have saved his father. In an effort to protect his son, Jonathan stopped him.  He told Clark to stand down and lost his life shortly after.  As these complexities began to surface, I was practically bouncing on my seat.

But then, Clark Kent became Superman.

When Superman meets his real father, Jor-El (Russell Crowe) he says “I have so many questions.”  But then he doesn’t ask any.  After one brief conversation, he excepts his true purpose and puts on the suit and cape and becomes Superman.  The whole revelation feels forced.  The internal struggle we saw in flashbacks disappears and Jor-El tells him he must always push his boundaries.  This is illustrated as he tests his ability to fly.

From there the movie kind of falls apart.  General Zod enters the picture.  He’s from Superman/Kal-El’s home planet of Krypton and longs to join forces with Kal-El and continue Krypton’s population on Earth.  Superman is not having it.  The first big fight scene takes place in Kansas in the middle of the street where the only warning to innocent civilians from Superman is to “go inside, it’s not safe.”  This is drastically out of character from the Superman we know and love.  According to Superman’s code of ethics, he would have moved the fight elsewhere.

In the story’s defense, I read an interview with Zack Synder and David S. Goyer where they reminded everyone that Superman is a superhero “in training.”  He’s bound to make mistakes and this would be one of them.  With that in mind, it still felt like a cheap ploy to create a dramatic fight scene.  At the end of the movie, there is another situation where Zod and his team pretty much destroy Metropolis and Superman is too busy creating the Phantom Zone to send Zod away. He doesn’t make much of an effort to prevent damage.  The big heroes of the scene are actually Perry White (Laurence Fishburne) and Steve Lombard (Michael Kelly) as they aid reporter  Jenny Jarwich who is trapped under a pile of debris.  At the end of the movie, there is no mention of the damage (much like in Star Trek).  It would have been nice to see Superman working to rebuild the city.

Here goes, EVEN MORE SPOILERS AHEAD!

Now the ending is where things get really messy.  Superman does the one thing that Superman just doesn’t do, he kills General Zod.

Superman is successful in creating the Phantom Zone and it send Zod’s team into the black hole.  But Zod is still around.  After about fifteen minutes of a glorified fist fight that continues the destruction in Metropolis, Superman finally gets the upperhand and traps Zod in a choke hold.  They are in a room with what appears to be a family of four (since the fight wasn’t taken somewhere safer).  Zod, playing with Superman’s humanity, turns on his heat vision and begins to aim it at the family of four.  He slowly inches it closer and closer to the innocent civilians, Superman is screaming for him to stop.  Just as it’s about to hit them, Superman does the unthinkable.  He snaps Zod’s neck.  As Zod’s lifeless body hits the floor Superman let’s out a desperate scream and is immediately comforted by Lois Lane (Amy Adams).  Two seconds later, he’s bickering  with General Swanwick.  Then Superman becomes Clark Kent and the origin story is complete.  Boom. Over. Just like that.

First of all, Superman doesn’t kill people.  He would sacrifice himself before killing someone, no matter how bad or awful they are.  Secondly, there was no grief.  This awful, terrible, no-good thing happens and there are no repercussions.  Superman should have been inconsolable.  I would have liked more of a conversation between him and Lois Lane where she helps him justify it. The end of the movie should have been more about his internal struggle and guilt, not a quick wrap up.

I walked out of the movie saying, “WHAT we’re they THINKING!?”  Luckily, I’m not the only one wondering and Zack Synder and David S. Goyer have provided an explanation.  In the original ending (by Christopher Nolan), Zod disappears into the Phantom Zone with his crew.  Synder and Goyer didn’t feel that was satisfying enough.  They explain their actions by reminding us (like previously said) that Superman is a baby superhero.  He’s still struggling to find himself and figure out his code of ethics.  Also he needed to kill someone so he has something to haunt him so he never does it again.

That’s great and all, but we didn’t see it.  Once he put on the cape and fights began, the complex Superman vanished to make room for fight scenes and mass destruction.

Don’t get me wrong, I thought Henry Cavill was perfect.  I loved Amy Adams as Lois Lane.  But that ending was just a complete disappointment.  My gut tells me that they should have listened to Christopher Nolan.  Then again, I don’t remember liking Batman Begins all that much either.  Maybe this is just what we should have expected.

What did you think?  Is Superman now a loose cannon?  Can he/should he kill again?  How did you feel about the reboot?

Advertisements

Author: elizbond

Creative Project Manager at the CFPB, Appalachian State alumni, Emerson College IMC graduate. Lover of movies, television, junk food, her dog Dexter, James Dean, and all things southern. North Carolina native, DC resident.

2 thoughts on “‘Man of Steel’ Character Flaws and That Ending

  1. Excellent post with realyl spot on points!!! I can’t even express into words how much I disliked this movie…but I’ll try;) (keep in mind I am a huge comic-movie fan so it takes a lot for me to be disappointed). This movie was at its best in the flashback scenes…they showed heart and turmoil and humanity. The rest of the movie was at its worst well…everywhere else, not at one specific point. Some things that really annoyed me:

    1) Clark’s dad dies of a heart attack. Everyone knows that. Changing a huge part of Clark’s history just for the corniesness of that scene is ridiculous and unnecessary.
    2) The sheer randomness of Lois and Clark meeting was so forced, their exchanges were forced and lacked any chemistry, build-up or mystery. 1/2 hour into the movie and she knows who he is, are you kidding me??? They’re in the snow, then a graveyard, then a military base, then the desert all in such a short span of time, the editing of their scenes made me think of a Calvin Klein Obsession commercial gone wrong.

    3) Don’t even get me started about the beginning on Krypton…way to jam several years worth of back-story into a few minutes. Seriously, your planet is literally dying and you waste time holding a trial for Zod and moments after they are sentenced, boom, the planet is gone. Anyway…. I totally agree with you about the interactions between Clark and Jor-El, everything there was forced. By the time the fight scenes started I was so bored and over the whole movie that I wouldn’t have cared if The Man of Steel himself got killed, let alone killed Zod. I was ok with anything that ended that HORRENDOUS fight scene. I was, however, super pi**ed at that uber inappropriate kiss…everyone in Metropolis is clearly dead but hey, why not make out now?!

    4) The biggest thing that got me throughout the movie was, why are they trying to do this whole Jesus/Superman thing? He struggles with being different as a kid, his parents try to shield him because they think he’ll be persecuted. He basically vanishes in his youth to randomly perform “miracles” around the world only to reappear at the age of 33 (same age as JC) in order to sacrifice himself for humanity after being conflicted about it (another random scene, now with a minster…was that his family minister, just a random one, what was that all about?). I just felt like the filmmakers were trying way too hard to push some kind of Superman as Jesus-like savior thing but instead of being interesting it just fell flat.

    5) I can’t even honestly say if Henry Cavill was any good or not.. Most of the time he looked confused or constipated, but I don’t think it was his fault. I think he was giving the director exactly what he wanted but I think the director was an idiot. It’s fine if he wanted to make SM conflicted and imperfect, but at least give him some soul, some humor, some sort of personality. The kids who play SM in the flashbacks showed more personality than Henry Cavill was allowed to. Same thing with Amy Adams as Lois Lane, I just didn’t see anything spectacular about her. Other than the fact that she said the word “dicks” to show her feistiness, there wasn’t much to her. The scene with her and Jor-El made me want to scream…”I’ll train you, and you’ll train Kal”….are there power points involved with this training, what is happening here?!?!?!?!?

    I get that he is supposed to be conflicted and new to this , so he is going to make mistakes. My issues aren’t with how they were going to portray this version of SM, my issue is with how poor of a job they did. The whole movie was forced, flat, heartless and humorless.

  2. Pingback: ‘Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice’ trailer leaks early | ROCK PAPER WATCH

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s